Audit Cost Analysis and Auditor Opinion

Oct 13, 2025 by talynt.org 44 views

The Influence of Audit Fees, Auditor's Company Reputation, Auditee Financial Condition, and Auditee Company Growth on Qualified Audit Opinion on Manufacturing Companies Listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange

Introduction

The quality of audit opinions is a crucial aspect of financial reporting, as it provides stakeholders with a level of assurance about the accuracy and reliability of a company's financial statements. In the context of manufacturing companies listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange, the influence of various factors on qualified audit opinions is a topic of significant interest. This study aims to analyze the effect of audit fees, auditor's company reputation, auditee financial condition, and auditee company growth on qualified audit opinions.

Background

The Indonesia Stock Exchange (IDX) is one of the largest stock exchanges in Southeast Asia, with a significant number of manufacturing companies listed on its platform. The quality of audit opinions is critical in maintaining investor confidence and ensuring the stability of the financial system. However, the factors that influence qualified audit opinions are complex and multifaceted. This study seeks to contribute to the existing body of knowledge by examining the effect of audit fees, auditor's company reputation, auditee financial condition, and auditee company growth on qualified audit opinions.

Methodology

This study employed a quantitative approach, using a sample of 22 manufacturing companies listed on the IDX from 2012 to 2014. The data was collected from various sources, including company annual reports, financial statements, and auditor reports. The study used logistic regression analysis to examine the relationship between the independent variables (audit fees, auditor's company reputation, auditee financial condition, and auditee company growth) and the dependent variable (qualified audit opinion).

Results

The results of this study indicate that the effect of audit fees, auditor's company reputation, and auditee financial condition on qualified audit opinions is statistically significant. However, when analyzed partially, only two variables show a significant effect on qualified audit opinions: audit fees and the average age of receivables. This suggests that both of these factors play an important role in the auditor's assessment of the reliability of the auditee financial statements.

Audit Cost Analysis and Auditor Opinion

Audit costs are a critical factor in the audit process, as they reflect the quality of services provided by the auditor. Auditors with a good reputation tend to charge higher costs, as they are expected to provide more in-depth analysis and assessment, as well as reduce the risk of inaccuracies in financial statements. The higher the audit fee paid, the more likely it is that the auditor will provide a qualified audit opinion.

Auditor Company Reputation

The reputation of the auditor company is also a crucial factor in the audit process. Auditors with a good name and high credibility often receive more trust from clients, which can impact the opinions given. Auditors from leading companies tend to provide more careful and detailed opinions in their audits, which can lead to a higher quality of audit opinions.

Auditee Financial Conditions

Auditee financial condition can be seen from various financial ratios, including OPM/TA ratio, current ratio, average age of receivables, and profit margin ratios. These ratios provide a clear picture of the company's financial health, which can impact the auditor's assessment of the reliability of the financial statements. For example, a high current ratio shows good liquidity, which can be a positive sign for auditors in providing opinions.

Company Growth

The growth of the auditee company, measured through various indicators, also contributes to the auditor's assessment. Companies that show stable and positive growth are often considered more attractive to investors and have a lower risk. This can affect how the auditor assesses financial statements and provides qualified opinions.

Conclusion

In conclusion, factors such as audit fees, auditor's company reputation, auditee financial condition, and company growth have a significant influence on qualified audit opinions. This study provides important insights for companies that plan to increase the transparency of financial statements as well as for auditors who want to improve the quality of their assessment. Understanding the relationship between these factors can help in better decision making in the business world and finance.

Recommendations

Based on the findings of this study, the following recommendations are made:

Companies should prioritize transparency in their financial reporting, as this can impact the quality of audit opinions.
Auditors should consider the reputation of the auditor company when assessing the reliability of financial statements.
Auditee financial condition should be carefully evaluated, as this can impact the auditor's assessment of the reliability of financial statements.
Companies should prioritize stable and positive growth, as this can impact the auditor's assessment of the reliability of financial statements.

Limitations

This study has several limitations, including:

The sample size was limited to 22 manufacturing companies listed on the IDX.
The study only examined the effect of audit fees, auditor's company reputation, auditee financial condition, and auditee company growth on qualified audit opinions.
The study did not examine the effect of other factors, such as industry type and company size, on qualified audit opinions.

Future Research Directions

Future research should aim to:

Examine the effect of other factors, such as industry type and company size, on qualified audit opinions.
Investigate the relationship between audit fees and auditor's company reputation.
Examine the impact of auditee financial condition on qualified audit opinions.

References

[1] Indonesia Stock Exchange. (2022). Annual Report.
[2] Indonesian Institute of Accountants. (2022). Code of Ethics.
[3] International Federation of Accountants. (2022). International Standards on Auditing.

Appendix

The appendix includes additional tables and figures that support the findings of this study.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) on the Influence of Audit Fees, Auditor's Company Reputation, Auditee Financial Condition, and Auditee Company Growth on Qualified Audit Opinion

Q: What is the significance of audit fees in the audit process?

A: Audit fees are a critical factor in the audit process, as they reflect the quality of services provided by the auditor. Auditors with a good reputation tend to charge higher costs, as they are expected to provide more in-depth analysis and assessment, as well as reduce the risk of inaccuracies in financial statements.

Q: How does the auditor's company reputation impact the audit process?

A: The reputation of the auditor company is also a crucial factor in the audit process. Auditors with a good name and high credibility often receive more trust from clients, which can impact the opinions given. Auditors from leading companies tend to provide more careful and detailed opinions in their audits, which can lead to a higher quality of audit opinions.

Q: What is the role of auditee financial condition in the audit process?

A: Auditee financial condition can be seen from various financial ratios, including OPM/TA ratio, current ratio, average age of receivables, and profit margin ratios. These ratios provide a clear picture of the company's financial health, which can impact the auditor's assessment of the reliability of the financial statements.

Q: How does company growth impact the audit process?

A: The growth of the auditee company, measured through various indicators, also contributes to the auditor's assessment. Companies that show stable and positive growth are often considered more attractive to investors and have a lower risk. This can affect how the auditor assesses financial statements and provides qualified opinions.

Q: What are the implications of this study for companies and auditors?

A: The findings of this study have significant implications for companies and auditors. Companies should prioritize transparency in their financial reporting, as this can impact the quality of audit opinions. Auditors should consider the reputation of the auditor company when assessing the reliability of financial statements. Auditee financial condition should be carefully evaluated, as this can impact the auditor's assessment of the reliability of financial statements.

Q: What are the limitations of this study?

A: This study has several limitations, including:

The sample size was limited to 22 manufacturing companies listed on the IDX.
The study only examined the effect of audit fees, auditor's company reputation, auditee financial condition, and auditee company growth on qualified audit opinions.
The study did not examine the effect of other factors, such as industry type and company size, on qualified audit opinions.

Q: What are the future research directions for this study?

A: Future research should aim to:

Examine the effect of other factors, such as industry type and company size, on qualified audit opinions.
Investigate the relationship between audit fees and auditor's company reputation.
Examine the impact of auditee financial condition on qualified audit opinions.

Q: What are the practical implications of this study for companies and auditors?

A: The findings of this study have significant practical implications for companies and auditors. Companies should prioritize transparency in their financial reporting, as this can impact the quality of audit opinions. Auditors should consider the reputation of the auditor company when assessing the reliability of financial statements. Auditee financial condition should be carefully evaluated, as this can impact the auditor's assessment of the reliability of financial statements.

Q: What are the policy implications of this study?

A: The findings of this study have significant policy implications. Regulatory bodies should consider the impact of audit fees, auditor's company reputation, auditee financial condition, and auditee company growth on qualified audit opinions when developing policies and regulations related to auditing.

Q: What are the future directions for auditing research?

A: Future research in auditing should aim to:

Examine the effect of other factors, such as industry type and company size, on qualified audit opinions.
Investigate the relationship between audit fees and auditor's company reputation.
Examine the impact of auditee financial condition on qualified audit opinions.

Q: What are the implications of this study for the auditing profession?

A: The findings of this study have significant implications for the auditing profession. Auditors should consider the reputation of the auditor company when assessing the reliability of financial statements. Auditee financial condition should be carefully evaluated, as this can impact the auditor's assessment of the reliability of financial statements.