Islamic banks in Indonesia should prioritize ROA and NPF when determining their profit sharing policies

Oct 13, 2025 by talynt.org 147 views

Analysis of the Effect of Return On Asset (ROA) Financing to Deposit Ratio (FDDR), Operational Costs for Operating Revenue (BOPO), Non Performing Financing (NPF), Net Interest Margin (NIM), and Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) to the level of profit sharing Mudharabah Deposits at Sharia Commercial Banks in Indonesia

Introduction

In the context of Islamic banking, the concept of profit sharing is a fundamental principle that distinguishes it from conventional banking. Mudharabah deposits, in particular, are a type of deposit that allows depositors to share in the profits of the bank, making it an attractive option for those seeking a more equitable and risk-sharing approach to banking. However, the level of profit sharing that depositors can expect to receive is influenced by a range of factors, including the bank's financial performance, operational efficiency, and risk management practices.

This study aims to examine the effect of several key financial indicators on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits at Sharia commercial banks in Indonesia. Specifically, we investigate the impact of Return on Assets (ROA), Financing to Deposit Ratio (FDR), Operational Costs for Operating Income (BOPO), Non Performing Financing (NPF), Net Interest Margin (NIM), and Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits.

Research Methodology

This study employs a quantitative approach, using annual data from 2010 to 2015 published by Bank Indonesia in the annual financial statements of Islamic banks. The data is analyzed using multiple linear regression methods to determine the effect of each variable on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits.

Main Findings

The results of this study show that simultaneously, all the variables studied affected the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits. However, partial analysis shows that only two variables have a significant effect, namely ROA and NPF. Other variables, namely FDR, BOPO, NIM, and CAR, do not show significant effects on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits.

1. Return on Asset (ROA)

ROA is an indicator that illustrates bank efficiency in using its assets to generate profits. The results showed that ROA had a significant positive influence on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits. This indicates that the higher ROA, the greater the bank's potential to provide higher profit sharing to depositors.

The importance of ROA in Islamic banking

ROA is a critical indicator of bank efficiency, and its impact on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits is significant. This suggests that banks with higher ROA are more likely to provide higher profit sharing to depositors, making them more attractive to customers seeking a more equitable and risk-sharing approach to banking.

2. Non Performing Financing (NPF)

NPF reflects the quality of financing provided by the bank. In this study, the NPF also had a negative effect on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits. The higher the NPF figure, the greater the risk faced by the bank, which can result in a decrease in the ability of banks to provide competitive profit sharing to customers.

The impact of NPF on Islamic banking

NPF is a critical indicator of bank risk management practices, and its impact on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits is significant. This suggests that banks with higher NPF figures are more likely to face risks that can decrease their ability to provide competitive profit sharing to customers, making them less attractive to customers seeking a more equitable and risk-sharing approach to banking.

3. Financing to Deposit Ratio (FDR)

Although FDR is an important indicator in Islamic banking, this study found that there was no significant influence between FDR and the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits. This may be caused by various internal and external factors that influence bank financing decisions.

The limitations of FDR in Islamic banking

FDR is an important indicator of bank financing practices, but its impact on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits is limited. This suggests that banks may need to consider other factors, such as ROA and NPF, when determining their profit sharing policies.

4. Operational Costs for Operating Income (BOPO)

High Bopo shows that bank operational costs are also high, which can reduce the level of efficiency. However, the results showed that Bopo had no significant effect on the level of Mudharabah deposit sharing, perhaps because the bank had managed its operations well, even though the operational costs were high.

The impact of BOPO on Islamic banking

BOPO is a critical indicator of bank operational efficiency, and its impact on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits is limited. This suggests that banks may need to manage their operational costs effectively to maintain their competitiveness in the market.

5. NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM)

NIM is a measure of bank profitability, and in the context of Islamic banking, its effect on the profit sharing of mudharabah deposits is not significant. This indicates that the financing and investment strategies implemented by Islamic banks are more focused on sharia aspects compared to interest margins.

The limitations of NIM in Islamic banking

NIM is an important indicator of bank profitability, but its impact on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits is limited. This suggests that Islamic banks may need to consider other factors, such as ROA and NPF, when determining their profit sharing policies.

6. Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR)

CAR is a measure of bank capital. This study shows that the CAR has no significant influence on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits. Maybe the bank has met its capital requirements, but this is not always directly correlated with increasing profit sharing received by the Depository.

The limitations of CAR in Islamic banking

CAR is an important indicator of bank capital, but its impact on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits is limited. This suggests that banks may need to consider other factors, such as ROA and NPF, when determining their profit sharing policies.

Conclusion

Overall, this study provides valuable insight into the factors that affect the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits at Sharia commercial banks in Indonesia. The results show that ROA and NPF are the main indicators that must be considered by bank management in determining profit sharing policies. By understanding this relationship, banks can be more effective in managing financing and providing better returns for customers. This research also opens opportunities for further research that can explore more about the factors that influence profit sharing in the context of Islamic banking.

The implications of this study

This study has several implications for Islamic banking in Indonesia. Firstly, it highlights the importance of ROA and NPF in determining profit sharing policies. Secondly, it suggests that banks may need to consider other factors, such as FDR, BOPO, NIM, and CAR, when determining their profit sharing policies. Finally, it opens opportunities for further research that can explore more about the factors that influence profit sharing in the context of Islamic banking.

Recommendations

Based on the findings of this study, the following recommendations are made:

Islamic banks in Indonesia should prioritize ROA and NPF when determining their profit sharing policies.
Islamic banks in Indonesia should consider other factors, such as FDR, BOPO, NIM, and CAR, when determining their profit sharing policies.
Further research is needed to explore more about the factors that influence profit sharing in the context of Islamic banking.

By following these recommendations, Islamic banks in Indonesia can be more effective in managing financing and providing better returns for customers, ultimately contributing to the growth and development of the Islamic banking industry in Indonesia.
Q&A: Analysis of the Effect of Return On Asset (ROA) Financing to Deposit Ratio (FDDR), Operational Costs for Operating Revenue (BOPO), Non Performing Financing (NPF), Net Interest Margin (NIM), and Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) to the level of profit sharing Mudharabah Deposits at Sharia Commercial Banks in Indonesia

Q: What is the main objective of this study?

A: The main objective of this study is to examine the effect of several key financial indicators on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits at Sharia commercial banks in Indonesia.

Q: What are the key financial indicators studied in this research?

A: The key financial indicators studied in this research are Return on Assets (ROA), Financing to Deposit Ratio (FDR), Operational Costs for Operating Income (BOPO), Non Performing Financing (NPF), Net Interest Margin (NIM), and Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR).

Q: What is the significance of ROA in Islamic banking?

A: ROA is a critical indicator of bank efficiency, and its impact on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits is significant. This suggests that banks with higher ROA are more likely to provide higher profit sharing to depositors.

Q: What is the impact of NPF on Islamic banking?

A: NPF is a critical indicator of bank risk management practices, and its impact on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits is significant. This suggests that banks with higher NPF figures are more likely to face risks that can decrease their ability to provide competitive profit sharing to customers.

Q: What is the limitation of FDR in Islamic banking?

A: FDR is an important indicator of bank financing practices, but its impact on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits is limited. This suggests that banks may need to consider other factors, such as ROA and NPF, when determining their profit sharing policies.

Q: What is the implication of this study for Islamic banking in Indonesia?

A: This study highlights the importance of ROA and NPF in determining profit sharing policies, and suggests that banks may need to consider other factors, such as FDR, BOPO, NIM, and CAR, when determining their profit sharing policies.

Q: What are the recommendations of this study for Islamic banks in Indonesia?

A: The recommendations of this study are:

Islamic banks in Indonesia should prioritize ROA and NPF when determining their profit sharing policies.
Islamic banks in Indonesia should consider other factors, such as FDR, BOPO, NIM, and CAR, when determining their profit sharing policies.
Further research is needed to explore more about the factors that influence profit sharing in the context of Islamic banking.

Q: What are the future research directions suggested by this study?

A: The future research directions suggested by this study are:

Exploring the impact of other factors, such as bank size, age, and ownership structure, on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits.
Investigating the relationship between ROA and NPF with other financial indicators, such as return on equity (ROE) and return on investment (ROI).
Analyzing the impact of regulatory and supervisory factors on the level of profit sharing of mudharabah deposits.

By answering these questions, this Q&A article provides a comprehensive overview of the study's findings and recommendations, and highlights the importance of ROA and NPF in determining profit sharing policies in Islamic banking in Indonesia.