The Current State of Permissions

Oct 13, 2025 by talynt.org 54 views

Introduction

In the world of Minecraft, permissions play a crucial role in managing server access and ensuring a smooth gaming experience for all players. As the game continues to evolve, the need for more advanced permission systems becomes increasingly important. In this article, we will explore the concept of adding separate build and destroy permissions for boats and minecarts, and how this feature can benefit server administrators and players alike.

The Current State of Permissions

Currently, Minecraft's permission system allows server administrators to control various aspects of gameplay, including building, destroying, and interacting with different types of blocks and entities. However, when it comes to vehicles such as boats and minecarts, the permission system is limited. Players can either build and destroy these vehicles freely or have no access to them at all. This lack of granularity can lead to issues on servers where administrators want to create public transportation systems or restrict access to certain areas.

The Need for Separate Permissions

To address the limitations of the current permission system, we propose introducing separate build and destroy permissions for boats and minecarts. This would allow server administrators to create more complex scenarios, such as:

Public rail systems: Players could place and un-place minecarts on a public rail, but not destroy or build on the rail itself.
Public ice highways: Players could place and un-place boats on a public ice highway, but not destroy or build on the highway itself.
Restricted areas: Administrators could restrict access to certain areas, such as a private minecart track, by denying build and destroy permissions for minecarts in those areas.

Implementation

Implementing separate build and destroy permissions for boats and minecarts would require modifications to the game's permission system. Here's a possible approach:

Add new permission nodes: Introduce new permission nodes, such as build.boat and destroy.boat, to control build and destroy permissions for boats. Similarly, add build.minecart and destroy.minecart nodes to control permissions for minecarts.
Override general permissions: When a player has a specific permission node set, such as build.boat, it should override the more general build permission. This ensures that players with the specific permission can build boats, even if they don't have the general build permission.
Integrate with existing permission system: The new permission nodes should be integrated with the existing permission system, allowing administrators to manage permissions for boats and minecarts using the same tools and plugins.

Code Contributions

We appreciate your offer to contribute to the code. While we are familiar with the codebase, additional help is always welcome. If you're interested in contributing, please let us know, and we'll provide more information on how to get started.

Conclusion

Adding separate build and destroy permissions for boats and minecarts would significantly enhance the Minecraft permission system, providing server administrators with more flexibility and control over gameplay. By introducing new permission nodes and overriding general permissions, we can create more complex scenarios and restrict access to certain areas. We look forward to hearing your thoughts and feedback on this proposal.

Benefits of Separate Permissions

Increased flexibility: Separate permissions for boats and minecarts allow administrators to create more complex scenarios and restrict access to certain areas.
Improved security: By denying build and destroy permissions for specific vehicles, administrators can prevent players from causing damage or disrupting gameplay.
Enhanced gameplay experience: Separate permissions enable administrators to create public transportation systems and restricted areas, providing a more engaging and immersive gameplay experience.

Challenges and Limitations

Code modifications: Implementing separate permissions for boats and minecarts requires modifications to the game's permission system, which can be complex and time-consuming.
Plugin compatibility: The new permission nodes may require updates to existing plugins, which can lead to compatibility issues and additional development time.
User adoption: Server administrators may need to update their permission systems and plugins to take advantage of the new features, which can be a challenge for some users.

Future Development

Expansion to other vehicles: If the separate permission system is successful, it may be extended to other vehicles, such as horses or donkeys.
Integration with other features: The new permission nodes could be integrated with other features, such as command blocks or redstone, to create even more complex scenarios.
Community involvement: We encourage the Minecraft community to provide feedback and suggestions on the proposed feature, helping to shape its development and implementation.
Q&A: Vehicles (Boat, Minecart) Permissions =============================================

Frequently Asked Questions

In this article, we'll address some of the most common questions and concerns related to the proposed feature of adding separate build and destroy permissions for boats and minecarts.

Q: Why do we need separate permissions for boats and minecarts?

A: The current permission system is limited when it comes to vehicles. Players can either build and destroy these vehicles freely or have no access to them at all. Separate permissions would allow server administrators to create more complex scenarios, such as public rail systems or restricted areas.

Q: How would the new permission nodes work?

A: The new permission nodes, such as build.boat and destroy.boat, would override the more general build and destroy permissions. This means that players with the specific permission would be able to build or destroy boats, even if they don't have the general permission.

Q: Would this feature be compatible with existing plugins?

A: The new permission nodes would require updates to existing plugins to ensure compatibility. We would work with the plugin developers to ensure a smooth transition and provide guidance on how to update their plugins.

Q: How would this feature affect gameplay?

A: The separate permissions for boats and minecarts would provide server administrators with more flexibility and control over gameplay. They could create public transportation systems, restricted areas, and more complex scenarios, enhancing the overall gameplay experience.

Q: Can you provide an example of how this feature would work?

A: Let's say a server administrator wants to create a public rail system where players can place and un-place minecarts, but not destroy or build on the rail itself. They would set the build.minecart and destroy.minecart permissions to false for the rail system, allowing players to interact with the minecarts but not with the rail itself.

Q: How would this feature be implemented?

A: The implementation would involve modifying the game's permission system to include the new permission nodes. This would require updates to the game's code and potentially existing plugins.

Q: Can I contribute to the development of this feature?

A: Yes, we welcome contributions from the community. If you're interested in helping with the development, please let us know, and we'll provide more information on how to get started.

Q: What are the benefits of this feature?

A: The benefits of separate permissions for boats and minecarts include increased flexibility, improved security, and an enhanced gameplay experience. Server administrators would have more control over gameplay, and players would be able to interact with vehicles in a more complex and engaging way.

Q: What are the challenges and limitations of this feature?

A: The challenges and limitations of this feature include code modifications, plugin compatibility, and user adoption. We would need to work with the plugin developers to ensure compatibility and provide guidance on how to update their plugins.

Q: What's the next step for this feature?

A: We're currently gathering feedback and suggestions from the community to help shape the development and implementation of this feature. Once we have a clear understanding of the community's needs and concerns, we'll begin working on the implementation.

Q: Can I provide feedback or suggestions on this feature?

A: Yes, we encourage the community to provide feedback and suggestions on the proposed feature. You can share your thoughts and ideas in the comments section below or by contacting us directly.

Q: What's the estimated timeline for the implementation of this feature?

A: We're unable to provide an exact timeline for the implementation of this feature. However, we're committed to working with the community to ensure that the feature is developed and implemented in a way that meets the needs and expectations of the community.