Use of transfer strategies

Oct 13, 2025 by talynt.org 119 views

The Impact of Translation Strategy on the Quality of Film Subtitles: Confessions of a Shopaholic in Indonesian

Introduction

In the world of film translation, the quality of subtitles can make all the difference in conveying the intended message to the audience. The film Confessions of a Shopaholic is a prime example of a movie that requires careful translation to ensure that the nuances of the storyline are preserved. This study aims to investigate the impact of translation strategy on the quality of film subtitles in Indonesian, with a focus on the film Confessions of a Shopaholic.

Background

The film Confessions of a Shopaholic tells the story of a young woman who is trapped in excessive shopping habits. The movie is a romantic comedy that explores the challenges of living with a shopping addiction. When watching this film, the audience is not only entertained by the storyline, but is also faced with the challenges of understanding the language and context used in the subtitles. Therefore, this study aims to describe the translation strategies applied by the translator in translating the subtitles of this film into Indonesian and examining the impact on the quality of the resulting translation.

Research Methods

The type of research used in this study is qualitative research. The data source consists of documents, namely the film subtitles Confessions of a Shopaholic along with its translation, as well as informants consisting of raters and respondents. The data under study includes phrases, clauses, and sentences, analyzed using interactive model analysis techniques, including data reduction, data presentation, and withdrawal of conclusions or verification.

Findings and Analysis

The results of the study identified eight translation strategies applied by the translator. The most dominant strategies are:

Transfer: 65 data (35.25%) - This strategy involves translating the source language text into the target language text without any changes.
Condensation: 54 Data (25.97%) - This strategy involves reducing the length of the source language text while preserving its meaning.
Paraphrase: 40 data (19.23%) - This strategy involves rephrasing the source language text in a different way while preserving its meaning.
Removal: 24 data (11.54%) - This strategy involves omitting certain words or phrases from the source language text.
Addition: 19 data (9.13%) - This strategy involves adding new information to the source language text.
Transcription: 3 data (1.44%) - This strategy involves transcribing the source language text into the target language text without any changes.
Imitation: 2 data (0.96%) - This strategy involves imitating the source language text in the target language text.
Desimation: 1 data (0.48%) - This strategy involves reducing the length of the source language text while preserving its meaning.

From a total of 152 data analyzed, it was found that 79 data (52%) of translation was classified as accurate, 65 data (43%) was less accurate, and 8 data (5%) was inaccurate. From the aspect of acceptance, 82 data (54%) of translations is declared acceptable, while 62 data (41%) is less acceptable, and 8 data (5%) is not acceptable. In terms of reading, 86 data (57%) has a high level of readability, while 66 data (43%) is at a moderate level of readability.

Impact of Translation Strategy

The application of transfer strategies, paraphrase, condensation, addition, and desimation shows a positive impact on the accuracy of translation. Conversely, the application of the strategy of removing, transcription, and imitation tends to cause lack of adolescence. This can be associated with the use of non-grammatical sentences, as well as foreign terms that are not yet familiar to the reader.

Difficulty understanding also arises from the use of Indonesian words that are not yet common, which can hamper the understanding of target readers. Knowledge of the cultural and social context involved in the film also plays an important role in determining the quality of subtitles. Translators who are able to adapt language and context appropriately will be more successful in delivering the desired message.

Conclusion

From the results of the analysis, it can be concluded that the translation strategy has a significant impact on the quality of the film subtitles Confessions of a Shopaholic in Indonesian. The application of the right strategy can increase the accuracy, acceptance, and readability of translations. Therefore, it is important for translators to understand these strategies in order to produce translations that are not only accurate, but also in accordance with the context of cultural and easily understood by the audience.

Recommendations

Based on the findings of this study, the following recommendations are made:

Use of transfer strategies: The use of transfer strategies can increase the accuracy of translation.
Use of paraphrase: The use of paraphrase can increase the readability of translation.
Use of condensation: The use of condensation can increase the accuracy of translation.
Use of addition: The use of addition can increase the readability of translation.
Use of desimation: The use of desimation can increase the accuracy of translation.
Avoidance of removal: The avoidance of removal can increase the accuracy of translation.
Avoidance of transcription: The avoidance of transcription can increase the accuracy of translation.
Avoidance of imitation: The avoidance of imitation can increase the accuracy of translation.

Limitations

This study has several limitations. Firstly, the study only analyzed the translation of the film Confessions of a Shopaholic into Indonesian. Secondly, the study only analyzed the translation of the film subtitles and not the entire film. Thirdly, the study only analyzed the translation of the film subtitles in terms of accuracy, acceptance, and readability.

Future Research Directions

This study has several future research directions. Firstly, the study can be replicated with other films and languages. Secondly, the study can be extended to analyze the translation of the entire film and not just the subtitles. Thirdly, the study can be extended to analyze the translation of the film subtitles in terms of other aspects such as cultural and social context.

Conclusion

In conclusion, this study has shown that the translation strategy has a significant impact on the quality of the film subtitles Confessions of a Shopaholic in Indonesian. The application of the right strategy can increase the accuracy, acceptance, and readability of translations. Therefore, it is important for translators to understand these strategies in order to produce translations that are not only accurate, but also in accordance with the context of cultural and easily understood by the audience.
Q&A: The Impact of Translation Strategy on the Quality of Film Subtitles: Confessions of a Shopaholic in Indonesian

Introduction

In our previous article, we discussed the impact of translation strategy on the quality of film subtitles in Indonesian, with a focus on the film Confessions of a Shopaholic. In this article, we will answer some of the most frequently asked questions related to this topic.

Q: What is the most common translation strategy used in film subtitles?

A: The most common translation strategy used in film subtitles is transfer, which involves translating the source language text into the target language text without any changes. This strategy is used in 35.25% of the data analyzed in this study.

Q: What is the impact of using transfer strategies on the accuracy of translation?

A: The application of transfer strategies shows a positive impact on the accuracy of translation. This is because transfer strategies involve translating the source language text into the target language text without any changes, which can help to preserve the meaning and accuracy of the original text.

Q: What is the impact of using paraphrase on the readability of translation?

A: The use of paraphrase can increase the readability of translation. This is because paraphrase involves rephrasing the source language text in a different way, which can make the text more engaging and easier to understand for the target audience.

Q: What is the impact of using removal on the accuracy of translation?

A: The application of removal tends to cause lack of adolescence. This is because removal involves omitting certain words or phrases from the source language text, which can lead to a loss of meaning and accuracy.

Q: What is the impact of using transcription on the accuracy of translation?

A: The application of transcription tends to cause lack of adolescence. This is because transcription involves transcribing the source language text into the target language text without any changes, which can lead to a loss of meaning and accuracy.

Q: What is the impact of using imitation on the accuracy of translation?

A: The application of imitation tends to cause lack of adolescence. This is because imitation involves imitating the source language text in the target language text, which can lead to a loss of meaning and accuracy.

Q: What is the most common challenge faced by translators when translating film subtitles?

A: The most common challenge faced by translators when translating film subtitles is difficulty understanding the cultural and social context involved in the film. This is because film subtitles often require a deep understanding of the cultural and social context in which the film was created.

Q: How can translators overcome the challenge of difficulty understanding the cultural and social context involved in the film?

A: Translators can overcome the challenge of difficulty understanding the cultural and social context involved in the film by:

Conducting thorough research on the cultural and social context of the film
Consulting with experts in the field of cultural and social studies
Using cultural and social references to help understand the context of the film
Avoiding cultural and social references that may be unfamiliar to the target audience

Q: What is the most important factor to consider when translating film subtitles?

A: The most important factor to consider when translating film subtitles is the accuracy of the translation. This is because accurate translation is essential for conveying the intended message of the film to the target audience.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the impact of translation strategy on the quality of film subtitles is a complex issue that requires careful consideration. By understanding the most common translation strategies used in film subtitles, the impact of these strategies on the accuracy and readability of translation, and the challenges faced by translators when translating film subtitles, translators can produce high-quality translations that accurately convey the intended message of the film to the target audience.